Comparing PC website browsing on iPhone 5 and Galaxy Note 2: The iPhone 5 is actually better

In my previous post, I concluded that the Galaxy Nexus with a 4.65-inch screen did not provide a superior web browsing experience compared to the 4.0-inch iPhone 5. On the contrary, the iPhone 5 displayed larger fonts on the same pages, hence reading the content was more comfortable on despite a significantly smaller screen. This was largely due to automatic font-resizing on the iPhone’s Safari browser.

I also briefly mentioned the Galaxy Note 2, and suggested that even with its 5.5-inch display which is 38% larger in length, fonts on PC websites would not be displayed as large as the iPhone 5. Hence, the browsing experience might still be worse despite a much larger display.

I have now obtained some screenshots from the web (I myself do not own a Note 2) so we can compare with actual images.

Below I used Galaxy Note 2 screenshots from TechRadar. I took screenshots on my iPhone 5 from the same website, and adjusted the sizes so that they represent actual physical measurements (meaning that you can directly compare font sizes).

Showing the whole page

The screenshots below were from The Daily Mail website. When displaying the whole page, second level headers were barely legible on the iPhone 5’s retina display. Second level headers on the Galaxy Note 2 were also very small, so we expect them to be very difficult to read as well. Since in both devices, the only text that could comfortably be read was the top level headers, we think there is little difference here.

Galaxy Note 2 full 2013 01 25 19 48

Zooming up on text

The next screenshot is where we move to an article page and zoom in to the text. The navigation column on the right is moved out of the screen. This is the “reading” mode where readers will actually read the text of the article.

As we saw in the previous post, here again we see that the iPhone 5’s font size is actually larger than the Galaxy Note 2, despite the latter having a 38% larger screen. This is due to mobile Safari automatically resizing the text.

Adding the fact that the iPhone 5 has a 326ppi retina display compared to the 285ppi Galaxy Note 2, the readability of the larger text on the iPhone 5 is clearly superior to the Galaxy Note 2.

Galaxy Note 2 zoom in 2013 01 25 19 50

Conclusion

With actual screenshots from the Galaxy Note 2, we can again see that the iPhone 5 provides a superior web browsing experience.

This is pretty damning. As the TechRadar article stresses, browsing the web is THE strength of the Galaxy Note 2. It is where the huge screen makes its mark. We also know that browsing the Internet is the most popular smartphone/tablet activity. Unfortunately, the much smaller iPhone 5 beats the Note 2 in website readability with the advanced software in mobile Safari.

The Galaxy Note 2 is great for browsing if your benchmark is other Android phones. If you have a choice though, I recommend the iPhone.

Software, not the hardware, is what makes the difference.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *